AI Scribe Vendor Agreements in Ontario: A PHIPA, IPC and CPSO Checklist

Tags:

Written by Mike Pearlstein, CISSP, MSc Computer Science (AI), CEO of Fusion Computing Limited. Fusion Computing has run IT and security for Canadian businesses since 2012.

An AI scribe records the visit, sends the audio to a vendor and returns a draft note. A July 2024 evaluation for OntarioMD measured “a 69.5% reduction in time spent documenting during clinical encounters” in a lab setting.

Neither PHIPA nor the CPSO prescribes a list of vendor clauses. The clauses in this checklist come from PHIPA duties, the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario’s 2026 guidance, the CPSO’s obligations, the OMA and OntarioMD tips and the Supply Ontario criteria. The IPC states that its guidance “should not be relied upon as legal advice,” and the same holds for this page.

For most physician clinics, the custodian under PHIPA s. 3(1) is a health care practitioner or the person who operates a group practice. In this guide “the clinic” means whoever holds that role, and that person signs the agreement.

Key takeaways

  • The custodian stays responsible. Section 5.1 of the IPC’s 2026 AI scribes guidance keeps custodians responsible for personal health information “even when using third-party vendors.”
  • The CPSO’s 2026 AI obligations say physicians are expected to “Obtain patient consent before recording conversations using AI.”
  • The Supply Ontario vendor of record list showed 28 qualified AI scribe vendors on November 13, 2026.
  • The OMA and OntarioMD AI Scribe Guidance Tips recommend an outer limit of 30 days for recordings and transcripts. The agreement should pause deletion for a patient access request or a legal hold.

What should an Ontario clinic get in writing before an AI scribe records a patient?

Fusion Computing recommends a signed agreement that fixes five things before the first recording. They are the vendor’s PHIPA role, use limited to the scribe service, no model training (a Supply Ontario criterion), the storage location, and deletion of audio and transcripts. The IPC’s January 2026 guidance, AI Scribes: Key Considerations for the Health Sector, adds disposal, subcontractor, cancellation and breach terms.

What the clinic remains responsible for after the vendor signs

Where the vendor acts as an agent, PHIPA s. 17(3)(b) keeps the custodian responsible for what the agent does. The Fusion Computing PHIPA compliance guide covers the custodian’s wider duties. The general rule is in section 5.1 of the IPC’s guidance, which holds custodians responsible for personal health information in their custody or control “even when using third-party vendors.”

Book a Consultation

Where does each obligation attach as scribe data moves?

Consent comes before the recording starts. Safeguards and the vendor’s PHIPA role govern the audio while it is captured, sent and processed. Physician review applies to the draft note, the CPSO’s 10-year minimum applies to the adult record, and deletion applies to the audio and transcript.

Where each obligation attachesAI scribe data flow, six stages1Consent at the visitIn the clinicCPSO: obtain consent before recordingIPC best practice: express consent,recorded in the health record2Audio captured on the deviceIn the clinicPHIPA s. 12(1): reasonable safeguardsOMA and OntarioMD: most physicians3Audio sent to the vendor and processedOn the vendor’s systemsPHIPA s. 10(4) and s. 17: vendor’s roleO. Reg. 329/04 s. 6(1), non-agent:use only for the serviceSupply Ontario: no model trainingSupply Ontario: Canada, or noticeplus equal security4Draft note returnedOn the vendor’s systemsIPC: logs of what the scribe wrotemay be needed5Physician reviews, note filed in the EMRIn the clinicCPSO: review all AI outputCPSO: adult record, 10-year minimum6Audio and transcript deletedOn the vendor’s systemsOntarioMD: delete once the note is finalOMA and OntarioMD: 30-day outer limitSources: CPSO, IPC, PHIPA, O. Reg. 329/04,Supply Ontario, OMA, OntarioMD.
The obligation at each stage of an AI scribe’s data flow. Sources: CPSO (2026), IPC (2026), PHIPA, O. Reg. 329/04, Supply Ontario, OMA and OntarioMD.

Want the PHIPA documentation for your clinic scoped as a project? Ask Fusion Computing →

What changed at the CPSO in November 2026?

In early November 2026 the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario replaced its policies with Professional Obligations. Its page Obligations in Practice: Artificial Intelligence says physicians are expected to “Obtain patient consent before recording conversations using AI.” The CPSO’s October 2026 Dialogue article says “no new expectations of registrants have been created as part of this work.”

What the AI obligations page expects

The page has one headline must. Physicians “must protect patient privacy and confidentiality and ensure the accuracy of information” when using AI tools. Physicians are expected to review “all AI-generated information before relying on it to support patient care.”

On documentation, they are expected to “Maintain accountability for their use of AI tools, including in clinical decision-making and medical documentation (e.g., AI scribes).”

The August 2025 Advice is no longer published

The CPSO’s earlier Advice to the Profession on AI, last updated August 2025, is no longer published on the CPSO site. The 2026 page is silent on choosing a vendor, so the agreement is where a custodian carries the privacy obligation through. Patient-facing wording is covered in CPSO AI disclosure to patients.

Is the scribe vendor an agent or an electronic service provider under PHIPA?

It can be either, and the agreement should say which. The IPC’s 2026 AI scribes guidance says vendors “may act as agents or electronic service providers” where PHIPA gives them authority. PHIPA s. 10(4) makes a supplier of electronic services follow the prescribed requirements. Section 17 keeps the custodian responsible for its agents.

The three restrictions on a provider that is not an agent

O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6(1) applies to a supplier “who is not an agent of the custodian.” It sets three restrictions:

  1. The supplier “shall not use any personal health information” except as necessary in the course of providing the services.
  2. The supplier “shall not disclose any personal health information to which it has access in the course of providing the services …”
  3. The supplier may give its employees access only where each one agrees to comply with the same restrictions.

Audit logs and the section awaiting proclamation

PHIPA s. 10.1, the electronic audit log section, has yet to be proclaimed in force. Section 6.7 of the IPC’s guidance still says custodians “may need to produce audit logs” identifying the records an AI scribe generated or altered. Those logs sit on the vendor’s platform, so access to them belongs in the agreement.

What does the Ontario AI Scribe Program list settle and leave open?

The Supply Ontario vendor of record list pre-qualifies AI scribe vendors against provincial criteria. It showed 28 qualified vendors on November 13, 2026, under an arrangement “effective from April 27, 2025 through to April 27, 2028.” The clinic still signs its own agreement and runs its own assessment.

What the criteria say

All PHI is stored and processed in Canada, with one exception. The user and buyer must be notified and told to put the information in their public privacy policies. The arrangement must comply with applicable privacy laws, and the location and cloud provider must meet “equal or higher security standards as those required of the vendor themselves.”

On model training, the page says: “The solutions cannot use patient information (even if de-identified) for training or improving their AI models” or for anything other than its intended purpose. It allows one exception: use “solely for the benefit of the clinician using it,” with identifying details removed.

What the list leaves to the clinic

The destruction criterion is worded as advice. The solution “should destroy all summary notes from patient visits” once the clinical note is in the EMR. The page states no breach-notification requirement.

OntarioMD’s program FAQ says the program offers no financial incentive at this time, and that Supply Ontario has set a minimum discount with each vendor. The free trial “typically lasts for 30 days” and “can be extended to 60 days.” For product differences, see the AI scribe comparison for Ontario family doctors.

Which clauses should an AI scribe vendor agreement contain?

Fusion Computing recommends 13 clauses for an AI scribe vendor agreement, each answering a named source. The CMPA’s AI Scribes: Answers to frequently asked questions, revised December 2025, supplies the liability test.

Why Ontario clinics bring their IT and security to Fusion Computing

CISSP-led, securing IT for Canadian SMBs across Toronto, Hamilton, and Metro Vancouver since 2012.

Clause Get in writing Source Red flag
1. PHIPA role Agent or electronic service provider, stated PHIPA s. 10(4) and s. 17; O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6(1) PHIPA never mentioned
2. Use limited to the service PHI used only to provide the scribe IPC 2026 s. 5.3; O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6(1); OMA and OntarioMD “Product improvement” as a permitted use
3. No model training or re-identification No training on patient information, even de-identified; no re-identification Supply Ontario VOR; IPC 2026 s. 5.4; CMPA 2025 Training on “de-identified” data
4. Storage and processing location The countries where PHI is stored and processed Supply Ontario VOR; IPC 2026 s. 6.5; OMA and OntarioMD No country named
5. Deletion of audio and transcripts Deletion at finalization; a 30-day outer limit; a pause for access requests and legal holds OMA and OntarioMD; IPC 2026 s. 6.3; PHIPA s. 13(2) No number of days
6. Disposal on request and at exit Secure disposal on request, and cancellation terms IPC 2026 s. 5.3; PHIPA s. 13(1) No exit terms
7. Breach notice and information Notice in time for the custodian to notify patients at the first reasonable opportunity, and the IPC where required; information for an IPC investigation IPC 2026 ss. 3.7, 5.3; PHIPA s. 12(2); O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6.3 No notice period stated
8. Security assurance evidence A yearly report (SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 or HITRUST r2) and independent TRAs and PIAs OMA and OntarioMD; Supply Ontario VOR A website badge, no report
9. Subcontractors Subcontractors named and bound to the same restrictions IPC 2026 s. 5.3; O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6(1) Subcontracting without notice
10. Access and approval logs Logs of who opened PHI, what the scribe generated or altered, and who approved it IPC 2026 s. 3.6 and s. 6.7 Logs the clinic cannot obtain
11. Patient access requests Retrieval of a recording or transcript still held OntarioMD risk guidance No retrieval path
12. Vendor liability The vendor answers for its own privacy or security failures CMPA 2025 All risk shifted to the physician
13. Notice of changes Written notice before changes to location, subcontractors, retention, features or model use OMA and OntarioMD; IPC 2026 ss. 5.3, 6.8 Terms changeable by posting online

Need managed IT and cybersecurity for an Ontario clinic? Get a written proposal →

When to settle the terms

Fusion Computing recommends settling the terms before the first patient is recorded, including in a free trial. After a trial it does not buy, the custodian must still be able to give patients access to their records and correct them. The IPC’s guidance says PHIPA obligations continue to apply “whether the service is paid or free.”

The OMA and OntarioMD AI Scribe Guidance Tips add a second reader: “OMA will review any AI contract submitted to [email protected].”

How long should audio and transcripts be kept?

Until the note is finalized, with 30 days as an outer limit recommended in guidance. The CPSO’s records obligations set a separate minimum of “10 years from the date of the last entry” for the adult medical record. The OMA and OntarioMD tips say recordings and transcripts “should not be retained beyond the minimum time required to perform the service, and in no case greater than 30 days.”

When deletion pauses

Deletion pauses for anything under a patient access request. Fusion Computing recommends the same pause for a legal hold. PHIPA s. 13(2) says a custodian holding information under an access request “shall retain the information for as long as necessary to allow the individual to exhaust any recourse under this Act.”

A custodian that decides to keep recordings should record that decision in a written retention policy. Section 6.3 of the IPC’s guidance says custodians “must carefully consider their legal authority” when deciding whether to retain recordings or transcripts.

Worked example: the retention dates for one visit

An adult patient is seen on Monday, November 2, 2026. The physician edits and finalizes the note on Wednesday, November 4. The agreement in this example requires deletion at finalization, so the audio and transcript are deleted November 4, two days after the visit.

OntarioMD’s consent toolkit offers sample wording for patients, which is true only if the agreement requires it: “We have required that any temporary audio recording and transcript are securely deleted once the note is edited and finalized by your doctor.”

The outer limit, measured here from the visit, falls on December 2, 2026 (November 2 plus 30 days). The adult record is kept to November 4, 2036 if that note is the last entry. In this worked example that is 10 × 365 = 3,650 days, plus 3 leap days (2028, 2032 and 2036), or 3,653.

How long each record is keptDays, worked example(record counted from the last entry)Audio and transcript2 daysOMA and OntarioMD outer limit30 daysCPSO minimum, adult record10 years (3,653 days)1101001,00010,000Log scale: each gridline is 10 timesthe one before it.Sources: OntarioMD, OMA, CPSO.
The audio is held 2 days in the worked example. The adult record minimum is 10 years from the last entry. Sources: OntarioMD, OMA and CPSO (2026).

Why the clause needs two triggers

Fusion Computing recommends two deletion triggers. The first is the physician finalizing the note. The second is an outer limit in days for unfinished notes, with a warning beforehand so the physician can finalize first. OntarioMD’s risk guidance names the risk: “You would be responsible if the AI scribe auto-deleted your historic files you did not have time to finish.”

What did a real AI scribe breach look like?

On October 27, 2025 the IPC published its response to a hospital privacy breach involving an AI scribe tool (Reported Breach HR24-00691). A former physician’s Otter.ai account joined hepatology rounds through a stale calendar invite and captured the personal health information of seven patients. The letter states: “The Tool has not been approved for use at the hospital.”

The IPC recommended that the privacy office contact third-party organizations directly to request deletion. It also recommended an offboarding audit to see that access, “including access to calendar invites, is immediately revoked upon departure.”

For an approved vendor, clause 6 puts the custodian’s deletion right in writing.

Unsure who secures the devices and accounts your scribe runs on? Talk to Fusion Computing →

What does the clinic keep doing itself?

Five controls stay with the custodian under any vendor agreement. The IPC’s 2026 guidance says “consent of individuals would generally be required” for an AI scribe. It also says custodians should conduct a PIA before introducing one.

  • Obtain consent and document it. The IPC calls express consent, recorded in the health record, a best practice. The OMA and OntarioMD tips add that patients must be able to opt out “without impacting the health care they receive.”
  • Review every note. The IPC expects every record a scribe creates or alters to be “reviewed by the custodian for accuracy” before use.
  • Post a notice. The OMA and OntarioMD tips say recording and retention periods “should be posted in your privacy notice/signage.”
  • Run the clinic’s own PIA. The IPC AI scribe checklist walkthrough goes through it step by step.
  • Adopt a written AI use policy that covers the scribe.

How Fusion Computing helps

Fusion Computing provides managed IT and cybersecurity to Canadian businesses with 10 to 150 employees, including healthcare clinics. The company is CISSP-led. Fusion Computing scopes and quotes PHIPA compliance documentation work as a project.

See managed IT for healthcare clinics and the guide to AI for healthcare clinics in Canada.

What to do next

Mark the vendor’s agreement against the 13 clauses. Download the CPSO AI policy template and adapt it into the clinic’s AI use policy. Settle the terms before the first patient is recorded, including in a free trial, and have a lawyer read the final version. Fusion Computing can scope the PHIPA documentation work as a project.

Talk to Fusion

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an AI scribe vendor train its AI on my patients' recordings?

A vendor on the Ontario vendor of record list cannot, with one narrow exception. The Supply Ontario criteria bar using patient information, even if de-identified, to train or improve AI models, except use solely for the benefit of the clinician using it, with identifying details removed. For any vendor, put the ban in the agreement, add a ban on re-identification, and treat training on de-identified data as a red flag.

Does a scribe on the Ontario vendor of record list still need its own contract with my clinic?

Yes. The Supply Ontario list pre-qualifies vendors against provincial criteria, and it showed 28 qualified vendors on November 13, 2026. The clinic still signs its own agreement and runs its own assessment. The criteria say a solution should destroy summary notes, and the page states no breach-notification requirement, so both belong in the contract.

How long can an AI scribe vendor keep recordings and transcripts?

Until the note is finalized, with 30 days as a recommended outer limit. The OMA and OntarioMD tips say recordings and transcripts should not be retained beyond the minimum time required to perform the service, and in no case greater than 30 days. The agreement should pause deletion for a patient access request, under PHIPA s. 13(2), or a legal hold.

Can an Ontario clinic use an AI scribe that stores data in the United States?

It turns on notice, security and responsibility. The Supply Ontario criteria keep personal health information in Canada unless the user and buyer are notified, the information goes in their public privacy policies, applicable privacy laws are met, and the location and cloud provider meet equal or higher security standards. The custodian stays responsible, so the agreement should name each country.

Who is responsible if the AI scribe vendor has a privacy breach?

The custodian stays responsible. The IPC's 2026 guidance holds custodians responsible for personal health information in their custody or control even when using third-party vendors. The agreement should require notice fast enough for the custodian to notify patients at the first reasonable opportunity, and make the vendor answer for its own privacy or security failures.

Do patients have to consent before an AI scribe records their visit?

Yes. The CPSO's 2026 AI obligations say physicians are expected to obtain patient consent before recording conversations using AI. The IPC's 2026 guidance says consent of individuals would generally be required and calls express, recorded consent a best practice. The OMA and OntarioMD tips say patients must be able to opt out without impacting their care.

Does PHIPA require audit logs for an AI scribe today?

PHIPA's electronic audit log section, s. 10.1, has yet to be proclaimed in force. Section 6.7 of the IPC's 2026 guidance still says custodians may need to produce audit logs identifying the records an AI scribe generated or altered. Those logs sit on the vendor's platform, so access to them belongs in the agreement.

Tell us your biggest headache across IT, security, or AI. We’ll let you know if we’re a fit.Get in Touch

Fusion Computing has served Canadian businesses since 2012, providing managed IT, cybersecurity, and AI consulting. Fusion’s CISSP-led team supports organizations with 10 to 150 employees across Toronto, Hamilton, and Metro Vancouver.

93% first-contact resolution. Named one of Canada’s 50 Best Managed IT Companies two years running.

100 King Street West, Suite 5700
Toronto, ON M5X 1C7
(416) 566-2845
1 888 541 1611